Top List
The 25 best pizza in Fort Myers: we read 5,927 reviews so you can just order (2026)
Fort Myers is a New York-slice town with a strong Chicago accent, and this is our read on the best pizza in Fort Myers right now.
The Local Desk · Fort Myers, FL · September 24, 2026
Key facts
Downtown House of Pizza tops this list of 25 places in Fort Myers, FL, ranked from 28,904 Google reviews, September 24, 2026. Cross-checked against 2 outside rankings. Nobody pays to be listed.
| # | Business | Rating | Reviews | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Downtown House of Pizza | 4.7★ | 5,433 | Best for downtown walk-ups |
| 2 | McGregor Pizza & Deli | 4.7★ | 1,245 | Best for a lunch order |
| 3 | Fine Folk Pizza Fort Myers | 4.7★ | 1,586 | Best for vegan options |
| 4 | Fat Tony's Pizza | 4.7★ | 190 | Best for a fast slice |
| 5 | Pizza D-LUX | 4.6★ | 516 | Best for takeout regulars |
| 6 | Lombardough's Pizza & Beer | 4.7★ | 630 | Best for a beer night |
| 7 | Blue Moon Pizza Fort Myers | 4.5★ | 1,122 | Best for dietary swaps |
| 8 | Uncle Rico’s Pizza Fort Myers | 4.7★ | 1,454 | Best for cheap pies |
| 9 | Amantia wood fire pizzeria | 4.8★ | 223 | Best for a small splurge |
| 10 | Little Sicily Pizzeria & Kitchen | 4.7★ | 406 | Best for two styles |
| 11 | 3 City Pizzeria | 4.7★ | 335 | Best for style hopping |
| 12 | Capone's Coal Fired Pizza | 4.4★ | 4,434 | Best for a group downtown |
| 13 | Pezzo Pizza + Bar | 4.9★ | 969 | Best for a first date |
| 14 | Tonys N.Y. Pizza @ The Forum | 4.6★ | 1,927 | Best for slice variety |
| 15 | Nice Guys Beer & Pizza Lounge | 4.6★ | 2,399 | Best for late nights |
| 16 | Baked (Formerly Buddyz) | 4.4★ | 748 | Best for Chicago transplants |
| 17 | East of Chicago Pizza | 4.6★ | 121 | Best for Midwest cravings |
| 18 | McGregor Pizza Company San Carlos | 4.8★ | 401 | Best for south end pickup |
| 19 | Pizzeria Di Biscardi | 4.9★ | 132 | Best for a small local find |
| 20 | Pizza 2000 | 4.3★ | 311 | Best for old regulars |
| 21 | Luigi's Pizza É Pasta | 4.7★ | 530 | Best for a friendly counter |
| 22 | Friend's Pizza Fort Myers | 4.4★ | 1,092 | Best for kids |
| 23 | Rosati's Pizza | 4.5★ | 510 | Best for takeout night |
| 24 | Luciano's Pizza | 4.6★ | 1,914 | Best for feeding a crowd |
| 25 | Fat Boys Pizza and Subs | 4.7★ | 276 | Best for a family order |
Here's the opinion up front: Fort Myers doesn't have one pizza style, it has two arguing with each other — thin, foldable New York slices from Hendry Street to McGregor Boulevard, and a loud contingent of Chicago pan, tavern and deep dish out by the Forum and down in Estero. The good news for the rest of us is that both camps are cooking well, and the best places here are mostly small rooms with a counter, a cooler of cans and a guy who knows your order.
By the numbers: we read 5,927 reviews across 150 places (100 each for the 74 contenders); 1,188 reviews specifically mention pizza; we checked 2 outside rankings for "best pizza in Fort Myers" (google.com/search, google.com/maps) and 16 of our 25 appear on at least one; we scanned 13 TikTok and Instagram posts about pizza in Fort Myers and 2 of the 25 are named in at least two; 28,904 Google reviews stand behind the 25 places listed; the list averages 4.64★ vs. a category average of 4.80★; and about 1,600 people a month search "best pizza fort myers". This list came from reading those reviews, not from recognizing names.
1,972
reviews read
28,904
Google reviews behind the list
4.64★
list average
city average 4.80★
1,600
monthly searches for “best pizza fort myers”
What reviewers mention most across the list: ny style pizza (586) · pie (465) · garlic knots (451) · chicago style pizza (344) · pizza by the slice (250) · outdoor seating (232)
- 1
Downtown House of Pizza
★★★★★ 4.7 · 5,433 Google reviews1520 Hendry St, Fort Myers, FL 33901 · 51 of 63 reviews read mention pizza (≈4,398 overall) · on 1 of 2 rankings we checked (google.com/search) · about 8,100 searches a month for its name · social proof: 2 TikTok/Instagram posts (1 TikTok, 1 Instagram) · 7.3 km from downtown
Best for downtown walk-upsny style pizzapizza by the slicepiecannoliThe Hendry Street standby is the most-reviewed pizzeria on this list by a mile, and 51 of the 63 newest reviews we read mention pizza — mostly thin New York slices grabbed at the counter, plus whole pies and white pizza. Prices read cheap, there's outdoor seating downtown, and people keep bringing up the cannoli on the way out.
Order this: A New York slice and a cannoli to go
Downtown House of Pizza Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 2
McGregor Pizza & Deli
★★★★★ 4.7 · 1,245 Google reviews4600 McGregor Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33901 · 61 of 78 reviews read mention pizza (≈974 overall) · on 2 of 2 rankings we checked (google.com/search, google.com/maps) · about 480 searches a month for its name · 3.6 km from downtown
Best for a lunch ordersubscalzonesstromboliny style pizzaThe only place on this list to turn up on both outside rankings we checked, and 61 of 78 reviews we read talk pizza — New York style, with garlic knots and stromboli riding shotgun. It's a deli as much as a pizzeria, so the subs and Italian beef move nearly as fast as the pies at this stretch of McGregor Boulevard.
Order this: A New York pie plus garlic knots and a sub
McGregor Pizza & Deli Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 3
Fine Folk Pizza Fort Myers
★★★★★ 4.7 · 1,586 Google reviews11300 Lindbergh Blvd #114, Fort Myers, FL 33913 · 66 of 84 reviews read mention pizza (≈1,246 overall) · on 1 of 2 rankings we checked (google.com/search) · social proof: 2 TikTok/Instagram posts (1 TikTok, 1 Instagram) · 10.1 km from downtown
Best for vegan optionsvegan optionspepperoni rollsny style pizzaoutdoor seatingOut on Lindbergh Boulevard near the airport, Fine Folk draws the most pizza talk of anyone here — 66 of 84 reviews we read name it — and it's the rare local spot where the vegan crowd and the New York purists both leave happy. Specialty pies like the lasagna pizza and the pepperoni rolls are what people photograph, and it's one of only two places on this list named in multiple TikTok and Instagram posts.
Order this: The lasagna pizza, or a round of pepperoni rolls
Fine Folk Pizza Fort Myers Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 4
Fat Tony's Pizza
★★★★★ 4.7 · 190 Google reviews9390 6 Mile Cypress Pkwy, Fort Myers, FL 33966 · 51 of 72 reviews read mention pizza (≈135 overall) · on 2 of 2 rankings we checked (google.com/search, google.com/maps) · 5.9 km from downtown
Best for a fast slicegarlic knotspizza by the sliceny style pizzacrispy crustA small 6 Mile Cypress shop with 190 reviews and both outside rankings in its corner; 51 of the 72 we read mention pizza, usually the crispy-crusted New York slices sold by the piece. Cheap, quick, and the cheese dipping sauce with the garlic knots gets named over and over.
Order this: Two slices, garlic knots, cheese dipping sauce
Fat Tony's Pizza Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 5
Pizza D-LUX
★★★★★ 4.6 · 516 Google reviews6810 Shoppes at Plantation Dr Unit 1, Fort Myers, FL 33912 · 60 of 66 reviews read mention pizza (≈469 overall) · on 2 of 2 rankings we checked (google.com/search, google.com/maps) · about 50 searches a month for its name · 4.1 km from downtown
Best for takeout regularsny style pizzapiegarlic knotscrustSixty of the 66 reviews we read here mention pizza, the highest hit rate on the list — this is a pizza-first counter in the Shoppes at Plantation, not a restaurant with pizza on the menu. Expect giant thin slices with a little flop, fair prices and a room that regulars describe as small and family-run.
Order this: A thin New York cheese slice, folded
“The za game is on point nice thin crust a little flop but still a good crunch with each bite”
Pizza D-LUX Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 6
Lombardough's Pizza & Beer
★★★★★ 4.7 · 630 Google reviews17081 S Tamiami Trl, Fort Myers, FL 33908 · 35 of 70 reviews read mention pizza (≈315 overall) · on 1 of 2 rankings we checked (google.com/search) · 9.8 km from downtown
Best for a beer nightoutdoor seatinggluten free optionsmargarita pizzacornholeBrick oven pies on South Tamiami Trail, in a room built for sticking around — cornhole, live music and a patio, with 35 of 70 reviews we read mentioning pizza. The margarita pizza and gluten free options come up most, and the beer list is half the reason people show up.
Order this: Margarita pizza, brick oven, on the patio
Lombardough's Pizza & Beer Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 7
Blue Moon Pizza Fort Myers
★★★★★ 4.5 · 1,122 Google reviews7381 College Pkwy #120, Fort Myers, FL 33907 · 35 of 58 reviews read mention pizza (≈677 overall) · on 2 of 2 rankings we checked (google.com/search, google.com/maps) · 2.9 km from downtown
Best for dietary swapsgluten free pizzaoutdoor seatingbar seatinggarlic knotsA College Parkway sit-down spot with bar seating and a patio, on both outside rankings, where 35 of 58 reviews we read talk pizza. It's the place locals name for gluten free, cauliflower and vegan crusts, though a few regulars think the toppings aren't what they were last year.
Order this: Gluten free pie and garlic knots
“I haven't had pizza this good since living in Chicago”
Blue Moon Pizza Fort Myers Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 8
Uncle Rico’s Pizza Fort Myers
★★★★★ 4.7 · 1,454 Google reviews2960 Cleveland Ave, Fort Myers, FL 33901 · 49 of 62 reviews read mention pizza (≈1,149 overall) · on 1 of 2 rankings we checked (google.com/search) · 5.1 km from downtown
Best for cheap piespiegarlic knotspepperoni rollsny style pizzaCleveland Avenue, cheap, and busy — 49 of the 62 reviews we read mention pizza, with the crispy-crust New York pies and pepperoni rolls doing most of the talking. The burrata pizza is the one people order when they want to spend a little more than a slice.
Order this: Burrata pizza, or a bag of pepperoni rolls
Uncle Rico’s Pizza Fort Myers Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 9
Amantia wood fire pizzeria
★★★★★ 4.8 · 223 Google reviews15245 S Tamiami Trl, Fort Myers, FL 33908 · 65 of 74 reviews read mention pizza (≈196 overall) · on 1 of 2 rankings we checked (google.com/search) · 6.3 km from downtown
Best for a small splurgemeatballswood fired pizzachicken parm pizzaaranciniThe highest-rated pizzeria here at 4.8★, and the most single-minded: 65 of 74 reviews we read mention pizza, nearly all of it wood fired. Come hungry enough for arancini, meatballs and garlic bread first, and note that the chicken parm pizza is the one people come back for.
Order this: Chicken parm pizza from the wood fire
Amantia wood fire pizzeria Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 10
Little Sicily Pizzeria & Kitchen
★★★★★ 4.7 · 406 Google reviews5611 Six Mile Commercial Ct Ste 3, Fort Myers, FL 33912 · 49 of 66 reviews read mention pizza (≈301 overall) · on 1 of 2 rankings we checked (google.com/search) · 5.5 km from downtown
Best for two stylespiegarlic knotspizza by the sliceny style pizzaTucked into a commercial court off Six Mile, Little Sicily runs both games — thin New York rounds by the slice and thick Sicilian squares — and 49 of 66 reviews we read mention pizza. There's a full kitchen behind it too, with chicken parm and garlic knots getting steady mentions.
Order this: A Sicilian square and a New York slice
Little Sicily Pizzeria & Kitchen Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 11
3 City Pizzeria
★★★★★ 4.7 · 335 Google reviews12901 McGregor Blvd #5, Fort Myers, FL 33919 · 56 of 81 reviews read mention pizza (≈232 overall) · on 1 of 2 rankings we checked (google.com/search) · 5.4 km from downtown
Best for style hoppingchicago style pizzachicago doggarlic knotsnew york style pizzaThe city's most indecisive pizzeria in the best way: Chicago tavern, Detroit and New York styles all live on the same McGregor Boulevard menu, and 56 of 81 reviews we read mention pizza. Prices sit on the inexpensive side, and a Chicago dog on the side is very much part of the plan.
Order this: Chicago tavern pizza, cut in squares
3 City Pizzeria Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 12
Capone's Coal Fired Pizza
★★★★★ 4.4 · 4,434 Google reviews2225 First St #201, Fort Myers, FL 33901 · 27 of 56 reviews read mention pizza (≈2,138 overall) · on 1 of 2 rankings we checked (google.com/search) · 7.4 km from downtown
Best for a group downtownmeatballsal capone themeoutdoor seatingbruschettaThe big downtown room on First Street, coal fired and leaning hard into the Al Capone theme, with outdoor seating and 4,434 reviews behind it. Only 27 of 56 reviews we read mention pizza — the meatballs and bruschetta pull attention — but the coal oven and gluten free pies are why it stays on the list.
Order this: Coal fired pie with meatballs to start
Capone's Coal Fired Pizza Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 13
Pezzo Pizza + Bar
★★★★★ 4.9 · 969 Google reviews20041 S Tamiami Trl #18, Estero, FL 33928 · 36 of 79 reviews read mention pizza (≈442 overall) · on 0 of 2 rankings we checked · 15.2 km from downtown
Best for a first dateitalian foodbruschettatiramisuhappy hourAt 4.9★ across 969 reviews, Pezzo is the highest-rated place here, though it reads as a full Italian restaurant first — 36 of 79 reviews we read mention pizza, the rest go to bruschetta, burrata and tiramisu. The spicy baby pizza is the one that gets named, and happy hour is when locals turn up.
Order this: The spicy baby pizza at happy hour
Pezzo Pizza + Bar Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 14
Tonys N.Y. Pizza @ The Forum
★★★★★ 4.6 · 1,927 Google reviews3398 Forum Blvd #101, Fort Myers, FL 33905 · 28 of 63 reviews read mention pizza (≈856 overall) · on 1 of 2 rankings we checked (google.com/search) · 7.7 km from downtown
Best for slice varietyny style pizzagarlic knotspizza by the slicepieA Forum Boulevard slice shop with almost 2,000 reviews, where the daytime slice case is the draw — hot honey, vegan and gluten free all show up in reviews alongside the standard New York rounds. Twenty-eight of the 63 reviews we read mention pizza; the rest are busy with stromboli, knots and pasta.
Order this: A hot honey slice from the daytime case
↗ 30 of its 30 newest reviews landed in the last 30 days
“Great NY style pizza, some interesting varieties in addition to the standard”
Tonys N.Y. Pizza @ The Forum Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 15
Nice Guys Beer & Pizza Lounge
★★★★★ 4.6 · 2,399 Google reviews1404 Cape Coral Pkwy E, Cape Coral, FL 33904 · 33 of 66 reviews read mention pizza (≈1,200 overall) · on 0 of 2 rankings we checked · 8.5 km from downtown
Best for late nightspinball machinesgarlic knotscraft beersvegan optionsAcross the bridge on Cape Coral Parkway, this is a pizza lounge in the literal sense — pinball, black lights, rotating craft beer — and 33 of 66 reviews we read mention pizza. The pies are the experimental kind, hot honey and dairy-free included, with tots and garlic knots to share.
Order this: Hot honey pizza with a rotating craft beer
Nice Guys Beer & Pizza Lounge Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 16
Baked (Formerly Buddyz)
★★★★★ 4.4 · 748 Google reviews3268 Forum Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33905 · 46 of 76 reviews read mention pizza (≈453 overall) · on 1 of 2 rankings we checked (google.com/search) · about 70 searches a month for its name · 7.6 km from downtown
Best for Chicago transplantschicago style pizzadeep dish pizzathin crust pizzaitalian beefThe Chicago outpost at the Forum, where 46 of 76 reviews we read mention pizza and transplants show up to argue about deep dish versus pan versus tavern-thin. It's pricier than chain pizza and people say so plainly; the beer nuggets and Italian beef round out the homesick order.
Order this: The Buckingham Fountain pan pizza and beer nuggets
“We got the beer nuggets and the Buckingham Fountain pan pizza to go”
Baked (Formerly Buddyz) Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 17
East of Chicago Pizza
★★★★★ 4.6 · 121 Google reviews4706 SE 9th Pl, Cape Coral, FL 33904 · 53 of 69 reviews read mention pizza (≈93 overall) · on 0 of 2 rankings we checked · about 1,900 searches a month for its name · 9.2 km from downtown
Best for Midwest cravingschicago style pizzapan pizzadeep dish pizzathin crust pizzaA tiny counter operation in Cape Coral with only 121 reviews but a big search following, and 53 of the 69 reviews we read mention pizza — pan, deep dish and thin crust, plus baked subs and wings. Go in knowing it's order-at-the-counter with a couple of tables, because that trips people up more than the food does.
Order this: Taco pizza with chicken, plus parm pops
“All were delicious, but our favorite was the taco pizza with chicken”
East of Chicago Pizza Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 18
McGregor Pizza Company San Carlos
★★★★★ 4.8 · 401 Google reviews18011 S Tamiami Trl #13, Fort Myers, FL 33908 · 54 of 69 reviews read mention pizza (≈314 overall) · on 0 of 2 rankings we checked · 11.3 km from downtown
Best for south end pickupny style pizzastrombolimeatball subgarlic knotsThe San Carlos shop on South Tamiami holds a 4.8★ and near-total pizza focus — 54 of 69 reviews we read mention it, almost all about crispy-crusted New York pies. Cheap, no-frills, and the meatball sub and Greek salad are the standard add-ons.
Order this: New York pie with extra-crisp crust
McGregor Pizza Company San Carlos Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 19
Pizzeria Di Biscardi
★★★★★ 4.9 · 132 Google reviews12541 Metro Pkwy #5, Fort Myers, FL 33966 · 55 of 80 reviews read mention pizza (≈91 overall) · on 0 of 2 rankings we checked · 2.2 km from downtown
Best for a small local finditalianpepperonipiecannolisA 4.9★ sleeper on Metro Parkway with just 132 reviews, and 55 of the 80 we read mention pizza — straightforward pepperoni pies at prices reviewers keep calling out. Add a sub and a cannoli and you've ordered exactly what regulars order.
Order this: Pepperoni pie and a cannoli
Pizzeria Di Biscardi Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 20
Pizza 2000
★★★★★ 4.3 · 311 Google reviews7101 Cypress Lake Dr, Fort Myers, FL 33907 · 43 of 75 reviews read mention pizza (≈178 overall) · on 1 of 2 rankings we checked (google.com/maps) · about 140 searches a month for its name · 3.8 km from downtown
Best for old regularsgorgonzola saladwhite pizzagourmet experiencemusselsA Cypress Lake Drive fixture that's been feeding the same families for decades, with 43 of 75 reviews we read mentioning pizza and a chunky homemade sauce people single out by name. The rating is the lowest here at 4.3★, but the white pizza and the gorgonzola salad have a long memory behind them.
Order this: White pizza, or a meat lovers with the chunky sauce
“We got a meat lovers and the white pizza both exceeded our expectations”
- 21
Luigi's Pizza É Pasta
★★★★★ 4.7 · 530 Google reviews10801 Corkscrew Rd #196, Estero, FL 33928 · 64 of 79 reviews read mention pizza (≈429 overall) · on 0 of 2 rankings we checked · 17.9 km from downtown
Best for a friendly counterwelcoming staffny style pizzapiethin crust pizzaWorth the drive to Corkscrew Road in Estero: 64 of 79 reviews we read mention pizza, thin-crust New York rounds and slices at inexpensive prices. What comes up almost as often as the pie is the staff — reviewers keep describing the counter as welcoming.
Order this: A thin-crust New York slice and garlic knots
Luigi's Pizza É Pasta Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 22
Friend's Pizza Fort Myers
★★★★★ 4.4 · 1,092 Google reviewsSun Sports Plaza, 3441 Colonial Blvd #10, Fort Myers, FL 33966 · 45 of 75 reviews read mention pizza (≈655 overall) · on 1 of 2 rankings we checked (google.com/maps) · 3 km from downtown
Best for kidswingsgarlic knotsstrombolisubsA Colonial Boulevard family room with booths, fast service and pies big enough to surprise people, with 45 of 75 reviews we read mentioning pizza. Opinions split — some call it their favorite, one recent diner didn't like it at all — but the hot honey pepperoni and the chocolate pizza have real fans.
Order this: Pepperoni with hot honey drizzle, chocolate pizza after
“My pizza was Pepperoni with hot honey drizzle- it was amazing”
Friend's Pizza Fort Myers Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 23
Rosati's Pizza
★★★★★ 4.5 · 510 Google reviews21301 S Tamiami Trl #400, Estero, FL 33928 · 50 of 69 reviews read mention pizza (≈370 overall) · on 0 of 2 rankings we checked · about 170 searches a month for its name · 17.4 km from downtown
Best for takeout nightchicago style pizzathin crust pizzapiedeep dish pizzaEstero's Chicago corner, where 50 of 69 reviews we read mention pizza and most of them are from people comparing it to home — thin crust, deep dish and a heavy hand with toppings. Takeout is the dominant move here, and reviewers say the pickup times hold.
Order this: The Classic Combo, thin crust
“This is a legit Chicago pizza. Generous amount of toppings along with excellent flavor”
Rosati's Pizza Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 24
Luciano's Pizza
★★★★★ 4.6 · 1,914 Google reviews728 SW Pine Island Rd #3, Cape Coral, FL 33991 · 39 of 63 reviews read mention pizza (≈1,185 overall) · on 0 of 2 rankings we checked · 14.7 km from downtown
Best for feeding a crowdny style pizzapiegarlic knotsstromboliCape Coral's high-volume New York shop on Pine Island Road, with 1,914 reviews and 39 of the 63 we read mentioning pizza. The 20-inch pies are the headline — the white one especially — and the Sicilian comes out crisp on the bottom.
Order this: The 20-inch White Pizza
↗ 27 of its 45 newest reviews landed in the last 30 days
“We ordered the 20" White Pizza from Luciano's, and it was absolutely delicious”
Luciano's Pizza Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 25
Fat Boys Pizza and Subs
★★★★★ 4.7 · 276 Google reviews3571 Del Prado Blvd N #12, Cape Coral, FL 33909 · 37 of 78 reviews read mention pizza (≈131 overall) · on 0 of 2 rankings we checked · 16.8 km from downtown
Best for a family orderwingsgarlic knotssubsny style pizzaA Del Prado Boulevard neighborhood shop where the New York pizza shares the menu fair and square with subs, wings and fried pickles — 37 of 78 reviews we read mention pizza. It's cheap, it's a 4.7★, and it's the kind of place you call on a Friday without thinking about it.
Order this: A New York pie with wings and garlic knots
Fat Boys Pizza and Subs Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
If you're choosing between the top three, go by what you actually want tonight. Downtown House of Pizza on Hendry Street is the slice-and-go answer — cheap, walkable, best when you want one New York slice and a cannoli on a downtown afternoon. McGregor Pizza & Deli is the sit-and-order-for-the-house answer, the only place here that showed up on both outside rankings, and the one to call when half the table wants a sub or a stromboli instead of pie. Fine Folk out on Lindbergh is where you go when you want the pizza itself to be interesting — specialty pies, pepperoni rolls, real vegan options — and it drew more pizza mentions in our read than almost anywhere else in the county.