Fat Tony's Pizza

9390 6 Mile Cypress Pkwy, Fort Myers, FL 33966

4.7 · 209 reviews

Combined from Google + LinkToReview

How was your experience?

Tap a star to share your experience.

 

About this business

Fat Tony's Pizza is a restaurant in Fort Myers, Florida, specializing in New York-style pizza made with in-house dough that rises for 36 hours and D.O.P. certified San Marzano tomatoes. The pizzeria bakes pies in a traditional stone oven at 600 degrees and sources premium Wisconsin mozzarella for a buttery flavor. Customers praise the hand-tossed pizza, stromboli, and garlic knots, alongside the warm, welcoming service that keeps them returning.

Local questions

Questions about Fat Tony's Pizza

Helpful answers based on customer feedback and business details.

What makes Fat Tony's Pizza dough different from other pizzerias in Fort Myers?

Fat Tony's Pizza makes its dough in-house daily using premium spring wheat flour and extra virgin olive oil, then allows it to rise for 36 hours to maximize flavor and crispiness. The pizzas are baked in an old-world stone oven at 600 degrees, which gives them a distinctive crunchy texture.

Related questions

What type of tomatoes does Fat Tony's Pizza use in their sauce?

Fat Tony's Pizza uses D.O.P. certified tomatoes imported from the San Marzano region in Italy, blended with herbs, spices, sea salt, cracked black pepper, and extra virgin olive oil.

Where does Fat Tony's Pizza source their mozzarella cheese?

Fat Tony's Pizza uses award-winning mozzarella shipped from a farm in Wisconsin, which gives their pizzas a delicious buttery flavor.

Does Fat Tony's Pizza offer garlic knots and stromboli?

Yes, Fat Tony's Pizza serves both garlic knots and stromboli alongside its signature pizzas. Customers have praised both items, with the stromboli noted for generous cheese and toppings, and the garlic knots as a popular side option.

Related questions

Are garlic knots and stromboli available for delivery?

Yes, Fat Tony's Pizza offers online ordering through Uber Eats and DoorDash for delivery, as well as dine-in and takeout options.

What customers say

  • The garlic knots are good a little bit doughy could use more garlic. The hand tossed pizza is really good. I Prefer New York style a little bit thinner less bread.…

    Joe · 4★ Google review

  • Quiet little place. Ordered a Stromboli and a slice while I waited for Stromboli. Pizza was closest thing I have had to NY pizza in years. Stromboli was crazy good.…

    TEDDY · 5★ Google review

What are Fat Tony's Pizza hours on Friday and Saturday?

Fat Tony's Pizza is open Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM. For other days of the week, the business operates from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM.

Related questions

What time does Fat Tony's Pizza open on weekdays?

Fat Tony's Pizza opens at 11:00 AM Monday through Sunday.

Disclaimer: These questions and answers are informational and are not official responses from the business owner or representatives. Please call or message the business directly to verify and confirm details on this page.

Good to know

Fat Tony's Pizza at a glance

Hours · Thursday
11 AM – 9 PMClosed · opens 11 AM
Full week
  • Monday11 AM – 9 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM – 9 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM – 9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM – 9 PM
  • Friday11 AM – 10 PM
  • Saturday11 AM – 10 PM
  • Sunday11 AM – 9 PM
Address
9390 6 Mile Cypress Pkwy, Fort Myers, FL 33966 Directions →
Rating
4.7★ from 209 reviews#8 of 25 restaurants in Fort Myers (city average 4.7★)
Details
Price $Website →

Nearby restaurants: Baked (Formerly Buddyz) (4.4 · 750) · Tonys N.Y. Pizza @ The Forum (4.7 · 2,255) · Friend's Pizza Fort Myers (4.4 · 1,097)

Featured by The Local Desk

Fat Tony's Pizza appears in these local guides, built from real Google reviews.

What customers are saying

Loved on Google

Curated highlights from public Google reviews.

TEDDY profile

TEDDY

Google reviewer

G

"Quiet little place. Ordered a Stromboli and a slice while I waited for Stromboli. Pizza was closest thing I have had to NY pizza in years."

Joe profile

Joe

Google reviewer

G

"The garlic knots are good a little bit doughy could use more garlic. The hand tossed pizza is really good."

Brandon profile

Brandon

Google reviewer

G

"The food was excellent, but the service Nonna provided made the experience truly unforgettable."

Villa profile

Villa

Google reviewer

G

"The most amazing pizza with delicious flavor. Meatball and garlic knots are to die for!!! even serve beer and wine. great atmosphere."

Kathy profile

Kathy

Google reviewer

G

"First time there and I was disappointed. Pizza sauce was good, cheese was sparse and if this is their normal crust, it's too charred and it..."

Fresh feedback

Reviews on LinkToReview

Write a Review

No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience.

Write a Review

Business snapshot

Fat Tony's Pizza in Fort Myers serves New York-style pizza with house-made dough and imported San Marzano sauce.

Fort Myers, FL209 total reviewsGoogle 209LinkToReview 0

Explore nearby

More restaurants near Fat Tony's Pizza

The Local Desk — best-of lists, hidden gems and reviews of the week, built from real reviews.

Own a restaurant like this one? Google Reviews for Restaurants: The Table Tent, the Receipt, and the Right Moment

Also in Fort Myers: Chiropractors (46) · Roofers (42) · General Contractors (35) · Dentists (28) · Veterinarians (23) · Eye Doctors & Optometrists (21)