McGregor Pizza Company San Carlos

18011 S Tamiami Trl #13, Fort Myers, FL 33908

4.8 · 411 reviews

Combined from Google + LinkToReview

How was your experience?

Tap a star to share your experience.

About this business

Brick-oven pizza with thin, crispy crust and charred marks distinguishes McGregor Pizza Company's Fort Myers restaurant location. The San Carlos Park pizzeria serves specialty pies like Gio's meaty pizza and fresh calzones alongside appetizers such as pepperoni poppers. Customers praise the attentive staff, quality ingredients, and welcoming atmosphere at this neighborhood pizzeria.

Local questions

Questions about McGregor Pizza Company San Carlos

Helpful answers based on customer feedback and business details.

What specialty pizzas does McGregor Pizza Company San Carlos offer in Fort Myers, FL?

McGregor Pizza Company San Carlos features specialty pizzas like Gio's meaty pizza and offers options such as cheese pizza with ricotta, calzones with fresh vegetables, and Mediterranean-style selections. The business uses fresh ingredients and a brick oven to prepare each pizza.

Is McGregor Pizza Company San Carlos open on Mondays?

No, McGregor Pizza Company San Carlos is closed on Mondays. The location is open Tuesday through Thursday from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM, Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 9:30 PM, and Sunday from 12:00 PM to 8:00 PM.

Does McGregor Pizza Company San Carlos offer dine-in and takeout options?

Yes, McGregor Pizza Company San Carlos welcomes customers for both dine-in and takeout service. Customers can call (239) 400-0965 or visit the location at 18011 S Tamiami Trl #13, Fort Myers, FL 33908 to place an order.

McGregor Pizza Company San Carlos at a glance

Hours · Sunday: 12 PM – 8 PMClosed · opens 12 PM
Phone: (239) 400-0965
Address: 18011 S Tamiami Trl #13, Fort Myers, FL 33908 Directions →
Rating: 4.8★ from 411 reviews — #7 of 27 restaurants in Fort Myers (city average 4.7★)
Details: Price $Website →

More restaurants nearby: Lombardough's Pizza & Beer (4.7 · 672) · FK Your Diet Fort Myers (4.7 · 1,915) · Pezzo Pizza + Bar (4.9 · 977)

Featured by The Local Desk

McGregor Pizza Company San Carlos appears in these local guides, built from real Google reviews.

Best Pizza in Fort Myers (2026): We Read 5,927 Reviews · Top List · Fort Myers, FL

What customers are saying

Loved on Google

Curated highlights from public Google reviews.

Tyler

Google reviewer

"⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 10/10 — Highly Recommend! Absolutely amazing. This is hands down the closest thing to a true New York slice that I’ve had in Florida. The pizza was excellent from top to bottom the cheese, the crust, the flavor, everything was on point. You can really taste the quality, and it’s exactly what I’ve been looking for in a great pizza. The staff was incredibly friendly and welcoming, which made the experience even better. We also tried the Greek salad, which was a perfect complement to the pizza, and the pepperoni poppers were excellent as well. All around, 10 out of 10. Great food, great people, and some seriously good pizza. I’ll definitely be back and highly recommend McGregor Pizza Company!"

Google reviewer

"McGregor pizza by far the high a quality pizza and great value ."

Seb

Google reviewer

"Pizza and appetizers here are amazing!! I always get the same pizza and it is good every time. It is my girlfriend and I’s “go to” pizza spot, no matter how far we have to drive. Eric and Cameron are the employees I see the most at this location and they’re both super friendly and outgoing. 10/10 would recommend!!"

Ava

Google reviewer

"The pizza here is fantastic!! I have been gluten intolerant for 12 years and Mcgregor has to have the best gluten free crust I’ve ever had from a pizza spot!! All the different topping options are fantastic. The customer service and different coupon/reward options are amazing. Cameron and Eric are who I see most often and they’re both so friendly and welcoming"