Tonys N.Y. Pizza @ The Forum

3398 Forum Blvd #101, Fort Myers, FL 33905

4.7 · 2255 reviews

Combined from Google + LinkToReview

How was your experience?

Tap a star to share your experience.

About this business

Tony's N.Y. Pizza @ The Forum serves authentic New York-style pizza with crispy crust and fresh ingredients in Fort Myers. The restaurant features an open kitchen where customers can watch food preparation, and offers catering services alongside traditional Italian pasta and wings. Staff consistently provide attentive service in a welcoming atmosphere.

Local questions

Questions about Tonys N.Y. Pizza @ The Forum

Helpful answers based on customer feedback and business details.

What type of pizza does Tonys N.Y. Pizza @ The Forum serve?

Tonys N.Y. Pizza @ The Forum specializes in authentic New York style pizza with hand-tossed dough baked to perfection. The business offers massive, fold-in-half pies including classic options like pepperoni and Margherita, along with creative combinations such as Hawaiian.

Does Tonys N.Y. Pizza @ The Forum in Fort Myers offer catering?

Yes, Tonys N.Y. Pizza @ The Forum offers catering services for events and gatherings. Customers can contact the business at (239) 931-7991 or visit http://tonyspizzafortmyers.com/ to inquire about catering options and place orders.

What other menu items are available besides pizza at Tonys N.Y. Pizza @ The Forum?

Beyond pizza, Tonys N.Y. Pizza @ The Forum serves traditional Italian pastas, wings, and subs. The menu includes items like chicken parmesan with pasta options, providing a full range of comfort food favorites alongside their signature New York style pies.

Tonys N.Y. Pizza @ The Forum at a glance

Hours · Sunday: 11 AM – 9 PMOpen now · until 9 PM
Phone: (239) 931-7991
Address: 3398 Forum Blvd #101, Fort Myers, FL 33905 Directions →
Rating: 4.7★ from 2,255 reviews — #18 of 27 restaurants in Fort Myers (city average 4.7★)
Details: Price $Website →

More restaurants nearby: Baked (Formerly Buddyz) (4.4 · 750) · Fat Tony's Pizza (4.7 · 209) · Friend's Pizza Fort Myers (4.4 · 1,097)

Featured by The Local Desk

Tonys N.Y. Pizza @ The Forum appears in these local guides, built from real Google reviews.

Best Pizza in Fort Myers (2026): We Read 5,927 Reviews · Top List · Fort Myers, FL

What customers are saying

Loved on Google

Curated highlights from public Google reviews.

Daniella

Google reviewer

"⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Tony’s NY Pizza in Fort Myers, Florida, is a great spot for anyone looking for authentic New York-style pizza in Southwest Florida. The pizza has that classic NY-style taste, with a thin, crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and a delicious combination of cheese and toppings. If you’re in Fort Myers and craving a good slice of New York pizza, Tony’s NY Pizza is definitely worth checking out. It’s a great local option for pizza lovers, whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch, enjoying dinner, or simply looking for a satisfying pizza experience. I highly recommend Tony’s NY Pizza to locals and visitors looking for quality New York-style pizza in the Fort Myers area!"

Brian

Google reviewer

"Their pizza is excellent. I definitely recommend Tony’s of New York Pizzeria."

Donald

Google reviewer

"Sandy was an excellent waitress, pleasant, helpful, and polite.. Garlic knots awesome! Eggplant tower is a fantastic appetizer. Old school pizza parlor vibe. Love it!"

carmen

Google reviewer

"Been searching for great pizza since moving to SWFL from Boston 11 years ago. Found it. Great pizza, staff and service"

Lya

Google reviewer

"Had a great experience at Tony’s! Danielle was super friendly, attentive, and made sure we had everything we needed. Her amazing service made our visit even better. Definitely coming back!"