Top List
The best auto repair in Sarasota: 25 shops we found by reading 4,932 reviews
We read every review we could to find the best auto repair in Sarasota, from Gantt Avenue to Bee Ridge Road.
The Local Desk · Sarasota, FL · October 13, 2026
Key facts
Sherman's Auto Repair tops this list of 25 places in Sarasota, FL, ranked from 7,520 Google reviews, October 13, 2026. Cross-checked against 5 outside rankings. Nobody pays to be listed.
| # | Business | Rating | Reviews | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Sherman's Auto Repair | 5.0★ | 400 | Best for honest diagnostics |
| 2 | D & R Automotive | 4.8★ | 208 | Best for low quotes |
| 3 | Automotive Service Garage | 4.9★ | 153 | Best for no upselling |
| 4 | A-Z Auto Repair | 4.8★ | 244 | Best for older cars |
| 5 | Sarasota Car Care (Auto Repair Shop) | 4.8★ | 124 | Best for close-in convenience |
| 6 | Accurate Automotive Repair of Sarasota | 4.9★ | 102 | Best for downtown drivers |
| 7 | Sarasota Mechanics Techs | 5.0★ | 233 | Best for a perfect record |
| 8 | Suncoast Auto Repair of Sarasota | 4.8★ | 258 | Best for urgent squeeze-ins |
| 9 | Kaufman's Auto Repairs | 4.9★ | 761 | Best for routine upkeep |
| 10 | Beiler's Auto Repair | 4.8★ | 425 | Best for second opinions |
| 11 | Jim Taylor Automotive | 4.8★ | 800 | Best for photo documentation |
| 12 | Sarasota Auto Repairs by Scotti's | 4.9★ | 61 | Best for a quiet bet |
| 13 | Jesse's Garage European Auto Repair | 4.9★ | 991 | Best for European cars |
| 14 | Stickney Point Auto Repair | 5.0★ | 204 | Best for warning lights |
| 15 | Freedom Auto Repair | 5.0★ | 85 | Best for electrical gremlins |
| 16 | Steve's Auto Repair | 4.9★ | 100 | Best for quick alignments |
| 17 | Mr Auto Repair | 4.9★ | 26 | Best for A/C work |
| 18 | Christian Brothers Automotive South Sarasota | 4.9★ | 525 | Best for stumpers |
| 19 | Keene Automotive Repair LLC | 4.8★ | 123 | Best for family fleets |
| 20 | Sarasota Automotive LLC | 4.9★ | 35 | Best for work vehicles |
| 21 | Dave's Auto Repair | 4.7★ | 223 | Best for long-haul loyalty |
| 22 | Hitchcock Automotive Repair | 4.9★ | 507 | Best for waiting rooms |
| 23 | Tom Dion's Automotive Repair | 4.9★ | 355 | Best for showing their work |
| 24 | Main Street Automotive | 4.8★ | 82 | Best for drop-and-walk |
| 25 | Elite Motor Works of Sarasota | 4.8★ | 495 | Best for downtown walk-ins |
Sarasota is a good car town, and that is not an accident: the shops people actually love here are small, owner-run bays where somebody named Sherman, Jimmy, Danny, Brian or Tibor walks out and talks to you. The pattern in the reviews is almost boring in its consistency — a straight diagnosis, a price that holds, and the car back the same day or the next.
We read 4932 reviews across 150 places (100 each for the 53 contenders); 230 reviews specifically mention auto repair; we checked 5 outside rankings for "best auto repair in Sarasota" (nottsautomotive.com, yourmechanic.com, instantcarfix.com, google.com/search, google.com/maps) and 19 of our 25 appear on at least one; 7,520 Google reviews stand behind the 25 places listed; list average 4.87★ vs. category average 4.83★; about 2,400 people a month search "auto repair". This list came from reading those reviews, not from reading names on signs.
2,121
reviews read
7,520
Google reviews behind the list
4.87★
list average
city average 4.83★
2,400
monthly searches for “auto repair”
- 1
Sherman's Auto Repair
★★★★★ 5 · 400 Google reviews757 Gantt Ave Suite 9, Sarasota, FL 34232, USA · 19 of 79 reviews read mention auto repair (≈96 overall) · on 2 of 5 rankings we checked (google.com/search, google.com/maps) · 6.3 km from downtown
Best for honest diagnosticsNineteen of the 79 reviews we read at this Gantt Avenue suite name auto repair outright, and they keep describing the same move: test drive, put it on the lift, then tell you it is too early to spend money. One customer with a 2009 Lexus had the diagnostic fee cut in half; another says a fuel pump came in at half what Firestone quoted, done inside 24 hours.
Order this: Ask Sherman to chase a faint front-end noise first
“they have definitely earned my repeat business and should be your first choice as an auto repair shop”
Sherman's Auto Repair Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 2
D & R Automotive
★★★★★ 4.8 · 208 Google reviews2225 8th St, Sarasota, FL 34237, USA · 7 of 77 reviews read mention auto repair (≈19 overall) · on 5 of 5 rankings we checked (nottsautomotive.com, yourmechanic.com, instantcarfix.com) · 1.3 km from downtown
Best for low quotesThe only shop on this list that showed up on all five outside rankings we checked, and it sits a short hop from downtown on 8th Street. Seven of the 77 reviews we read mention auto repair, and the word that repeats is "low" — prices, pressure and drama all kept down.
“Prices are low. I’m very pleased with this automotive repair company”
D & R Automotive Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 3
Automotive Service Garage
★★★★★ 4.9 · 153 Google reviews6219 Clark Center Ave, Sarasota, FL 34238, USA · 8 of 73 reviews read mention auto repair (≈17 overall) · on 4 of 5 rankings we checked (nottsautomotive.com, yourmechanic.com, instantcarfix.com) · 8.9 km from downtown
Best for no upsellingOut on Clark Center Avenue toward Palmer Ranch, ASG is the rare shop where reviewers list the whole crew by name — Frankie, Aaron, Pat, Jason, Marco. Eight of the 73 reviews we read mention auto repair, and "no upselling" comes up as often as the quality of the work itself.
Order this: Ask Aaron to diagnose and call you before anything starts
“Great place for all your automotive repairs and maintenance. You can be sure to get good value and no upselling”
Automotive Service Garage Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 4
A-Z Auto Repair
★★★★★ 4.8 · 244 Google reviews6360 Danner Dr, Sarasota, FL 34240, USA · 18 of 80 reviews read mention auto repair (≈55 overall) · on 2 of 5 rankings we checked (google.com/search, google.com/maps) · 7.6 km from downtown
Best for older carsEighteen of the 80 reviews we read at the Danner Drive shop name auto repair, and the details are oddly specific: a bill that landed two dollars under the estimate, a clean waiting room with easy-listening on, a 23-year-old Toyota fixed without a pitch for more. Howard gets named again and again for calling with updates.
Order this: Ask for the top-to-bottom vehicle physical before you trade up
“You will not find a better place to have your vehicles serviced than A-Z Auto Repair”
A-Z Auto Repair Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 5
Sarasota Car Care (Auto Repair Shop)
★★★★★ 4.8 · 124 Google reviews1767 Snug Harbor Pl, Sarasota, FL 34234, USA · 5 of 64 reviews read mention auto repair (≈10 overall) · on 5 of 5 rankings we checked (nottsautomotive.com, yourmechanic.com, instantcarfix.com) · 2.2 km from downtown
Best for close-in convenienceA small Snug Harbor Place operation just north of downtown with 4.8 stars from 124 Google reviews, and one of only two shops here to land on all five outside rankings we checked. Five of the 64 reviews we read mention auto repair, so it is a quieter paper trail than the big names — but a consistent one.
Sarasota Car Care (Auto Repair Shop) Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 6
Accurate Automotive Repair of Sarasota
★★★★★ 4.9 · 102 Google reviews2069 Cornell St, Sarasota, FL 34237, USA · 9 of 73 reviews read mention auto repair (≈13 overall) · on 4 of 5 rankings we checked (nottsautomotive.com, yourmechanic.com, google.com/search) · 1.7 km from downtown
Best for downtown driversCornell Street, barely a mile and a half from downtown, 4.9 stars across 102 reviews — the kind of tucked-away shop you only hear about from a neighbor. Nine of the 73 reviews we read mention auto repair, and it turned up on four of the five outside rankings we read.
Accurate Automotive Repair of Sarasota Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 7
Sarasota Mechanics Techs
★★★★★ 5 · 233 Google reviews1752 Apex Rd Unit b, Sarasota, FL 34240, USA · 2 of 85 reviews read mention auto repair (≈5 overall) · on 4 of 5 rankings we checked (nottsautomotive.com, yourmechanic.com, instantcarfix.com) · 7.7 km from downtown
Best for a perfect recordA clean 5.0 across 233 Google reviews out on Apex Road, and four of the five outside guides we checked list it. Only 2 of the 85 reviews we read use the phrase auto repair, which tells you people here write about the person who helped them more than the category.
Sarasota Mechanics Techs Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 8
Suncoast Auto Repair of Sarasota
★★★★★ 4.8 · 258 Google reviews2221 17th St, Sarasota, FL 34234, USA · 18 of 92 reviews read mention auto repair (≈50 overall) · on 2 of 5 rankings we checked (google.com/search, google.com/maps) · 2.2 km from downtown
Best for urgent squeeze-insEighteen of the 92 reviews we read at the 17th Street shop mention auto repair, and the Jorge stories run the same way: already booked solid, still finds a way to look at your car. A college student who could not get seen anywhere else for a week got in and, in her words, did not get ripped off.
Order this: Ask Jorge if he can squeeze you in today
“Jorge from Suncoast Auto Repair was also busy but his daughter spoke to him about my problem”
Suncoast Auto Repair of Sarasota Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 9
Kaufman's Auto Repairs
★★★★★ 4.9 · 761 Google reviews6831-A Whitfield Industrial Ave, Sarasota, FL 34243, USA · 10 of 75 reviews read mention auto repair (≈101 overall) · on 1 of 5 rankings we checked (google.com/search) · 9.7 km from downtown
Best for routine upkeepThe biggest reputation on the list north of Whitfield, with 4.9 stars from 761 Google reviews and roughly 101 of them touching auto repair; 10 of the 75 we read do. Regulars call it well organized and fairly priced, though one reviewer arrived for a booked appointment only to learn the job was not something they do — worth confirming on the phone.
“Kaufman's Auto Repairs is very well organized place,everyone is nice and knowledgeable,price is right,job done well”
Kaufman's Auto Repairs Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 10
Beiler's Auto Repair
★★★★★ 4.8 · 425 Google reviews5820 Palmer Blvd, Sarasota, FL 34232, USA · 17 of 81 reviews read mention auto repair (≈89 overall) · on 1 of 5 rankings we checked (google.com/search) · 6.6 km from downtown
Best for second opinionsSeventeen of the 81 reviews we read on Palmer Boulevard name auto repair, and Danny's name carries most of them — including a Ford Fusion owner he re-inspected free two years after a timing belt job and a Toyota owner who dodged a dealer's "critical" thermostat repair that did not exist. A couple of one-star reviewers push back hard on diagnostic pricing, so get the hourly and the cap in writing.
Order this: Bring a dealer quote in for a second opinion
“Extremely friendly, professional, efficient and most importantly honest (which is hard to find in the auto repair world)”
Beiler's Auto Repair Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 11
Jim Taylor Automotive
★★★★★ 4.8 · 800 Google reviews1051 N Washington Blvd, Sarasota, FL 34236, USA · 5 of 86 reviews read mention auto repair (≈47 overall) · on 2 of 5 rankings we checked (google.com/search, google.com/maps) · 1.9 km from downtown
Best for photo documentationEight hundred Google reviews on North Washington Boulevard, which makes this the busiest front desk in this part of town; 5 of the 86 reviews we read mention auto repair. What people single out is the paperwork: photographs of the issue and the diagnostic work that led to the repair, plus next-day appointments when you call.
Order this: Ask for the photo diagnostic report with your estimate
“Great service experience. Maybe the best auto repair shop in Sarasota”
Jim Taylor Automotive Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 12
Sarasota Auto Repairs by Scotti's
★★★★★ 4.9 · 61 Google reviews3855 S Tuttle Ave, Sarasota, FL 34239, USA · 2 of 50 reviews read mention auto repair (≈2 overall) · on 5 of 5 rankings we checked (nottsautomotive.com, yourmechanic.com, instantcarfix.com) · 3.8 km from downtown
Best for a quiet betThe smallest review count in the top half — 61 Google reviews at 4.9 on South Tuttle — but it appeared on all five of the outside rankings we checked, which almost nothing else did. Two of the 50 reviews we read mention auto repair, so this is a shop that gets recommended more than it gets written up.
Sarasota Auto Repairs by Scotti's Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 13
Jesse's Garage European Auto Repair
★★★★★ 4.9 · 991 Google reviews2400 12th St, Sarasota, FL 34237, USA · 4 of 80 reviews read mention auto repair (≈50 overall) · on 2 of 5 rankings we checked (google.com/search, google.com/maps) · 1.7 km from downtown
Best for European carsNearly a thousand Google reviews on 12th Street, and the name tells you the lane: European cars, close enough to downtown to drop off and walk. Four of the 80 reviews we read mention auto repair, with roughly 50 touching it overall.
Jesse's Garage European Auto Repair Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 14
Stickney Point Auto Repair
★★★★★ 5 · 204 Google reviews2640 Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, FL 34231, USA · 18 of 84 reviews read mention auto repair (≈44 overall) · on 0 of 5 rankings we checked · 7.5 km from downtown
Best for warning lightsA straight 5.0 from 204 reviews on Stickney Point Road, with 18 of the 84 reviews we read naming auto repair — one of the densest showings on this list, and it reached that without appearing on a single outside ranking. Typical story: three warning lights traced to one sensor, part ordered, car out the door inside an hour.
Order this: Ask Jimmy to trace warning lights before replacing parts
“I've never seen an auto repair with that high of a rating”
Stickney Point Auto Repair Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 15
Freedom Auto Repair
★★★★★ 5 · 85 Google reviews1749 Cattlemen Rd, Sarasota, FL 34232, USA · 10 of 59 reviews read mention auto repair (≈14 overall) · on 0 of 5 rankings we checked · about 50 searches a month for its name · 7 km from downtown
Best for electrical gremlinsTen of the 59 reviews we read at this Cattlemen Road shop mention auto repair, a high share for a place with 85 Google reviews and about 50 name searches a month. Brian is the draw, and the praise is unusually technical: electrical gremlins other shops missed, work fleets kept running, one customer fifteen years deep.
Order this: Bring Brian the electrical fault nobody else could find
“Freedom Auto Repair is easily one of the best auto repair shops in Sarasota, and Brian, the owner, is the real deal”
Freedom Auto Repair Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 16
Steve's Auto Repair
★★★★★ 4.9 · 100 Google reviews5814 Palmer Blvd, Sarasota, FL 34232, USA · 15 of 75 reviews read mention auto repair (≈20 overall) · on 0 of 5 rankings we checked · 6.6 km from downtown
Best for quick alignmentsSame Palmer Boulevard block as Beiler's, much smaller book — 100 Google reviews at 4.9, with 15 of the 75 we read naming auto repair. Stephanie runs the front, and the in-and-out alignment is the job people come back to describe: an hour, and the pull to the right gone.
Order this: Wheel alignment, booked with Stephanie
“I recently had a wheel alignment done at Steve's Auto Repair, and the experience was excellent!”
Steve's Auto Repair Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 17
Mr Auto Repair
★★★★★ 4.9 · 26 Google reviews2161 19th St, Sarasota, FL 34234, USA · 1 of 19 reviews read mention auto repair (≈1 overall) · on 3 of 5 rankings we checked (nottsautomotive.com, yourmechanic.com, instantcarfix.com) · about 720 searches a month for its name · 2.5 km from downtown
Best for A/C workThe odd one out: just 26 Google reviews on 19th Street, but about 720 people a month search the name and three of five outside guides list it. One of the 19 reviews we read mentions auto repair, praising a job done on time at the price quoted, with cold A/C at the end of it.
Order this: Get the price quoted up front, then hold them to it
Mr Auto Repair Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 18
Christian Brothers Automotive South Sarasota
★★★★★ 4.9 · 525 Google reviews5869 Derek Ave, Sarasota, FL 34238, USA · 6 of 84 reviews read mention auto repair (≈38 overall) · on 0 of 5 rankings we checked · about 320 searches a month for its name · 8.2 km from downtown
Best for stumpersThe Derek Ave shop off Honore in south Sarasota carries 4.9 stars from 525 reviews and about 320 name searches a month; 6 of the 84 reviews we read mention auto repair. The recurring note is diagnosis — people arrive after other shops have given up and leave knowing what was wrong.
Order this: Bring the problem other shops could not identify
“The only auto repair shop that was able to tell what was wrong with the car”
Christian Brothers Automotive South Sarasota Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 19
Keene Automotive Repair LLC
★★★★★ 4.8 · 123 Google reviews1171 Snead Ave, Sarasota, FL 34237, USA · 8 of 64 reviews read mention auto repair (≈15 overall) · on 2 of 5 rankings we checked (google.com/search, google.com/maps) · 1.6 km from downtown
Best for family fleetsA family shop on Snead Avenue where 8 of the 64 reviews we read name auto repair and the customers tend to be decade-long regulars with mixed fleets. One family credits Mike's crew with keeping a 23-year-old Ford truck running and still brings the newer cars here instead of the dealership.
Order this: Tires, oil changes and A/C repairs with Mike
“Very honest auto repair shop with reasonable prices”
Keene Automotive Repair LLC Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 20
Sarasota Automotive LLC
★★★★★ 4.9 · 35 Google reviews5671 McIntosh Rd, Sarasota, FL 34233, USA · 3 of 28 reviews read mention auto repair (≈4 overall) · on 3 of 5 rankings we checked (nottsautomotive.com, yourmechanic.com, instantcarfix.com) · 7.9 km from downtown
Best for work vehiclesTibor's McIntosh Road shop has only 35 Google reviews, but 3 of the 28 we read name auto repair and three outside guides list it. The reviews skew toward people with a lot of vehicles — an Infiniti G37, a Lexus GX470, RAM work vans, a five-truck fleet — and same-day turnarounds well under dealer pricing.
Order this: Ask Tibor about fleet and work-van maintenance
Sarasota Automotive LLC Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 21
Dave's Auto Repair
★★★★★ 4.7 · 223 Google reviews4547 Bee Ridge Rd, Sarasota, FL 34233, USA · 20 of 79 reviews read mention auto repair (≈56 overall) · on 0 of 5 rankings we checked · about 90 searches a month for its name · 5.6 km from downtown
Best for long-haul loyaltyTwenty of the 79 reviews we read on Bee Ridge Road name auto repair — the highest count on this list — and many come from families twenty years deep, plus a Fiat 500L owner who had given up. Mike and Ethan once sent a Genesis owner back to the dealer because the A/C was still under warranty; a detailed one-star review disputes a Porsche transfer case job, so ask about programming on complex work.
Order this: A/C diagnostics and wheel speed sensor replacement
“Had Dave's Auto Repair replace dead Wheel Speed Sensors in both rear wheel assemblies of my KIA Soul”
Dave's Auto Repair Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 22
Hitchcock Automotive Repair
★★★★★ 4.9 · 507 Google reviews5201 McIntosh Rd Unit A, Sarasota, FL 34233, USA · 7 of 86 reviews read mention auto repair (≈41 overall) · on 1 of 5 rankings we checked (google.com/search) · 7.2 km from downtown
Best for waiting roomsSeven of the 86 reviews we read at the McIntosh Road unit mention auto repair, and people notice the room as much as the work — bright, clean, inviting, which is not how most bays read. A stripped oil drain plug got fixed in about an hour; a towed-in no-start got a battery the same day.
Order this: Stripped oil drain plug repair while you wait
Hitchcock Automotive Repair Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 23
Tom Dion's Automotive Repair
★★★★★ 4.9 · 355 Google reviews5308 Ashton Ct, Sarasota, FL 34233, USA · 13 of 79 reviews read mention auto repair (≈58 overall) · on 0 of 5 rankings we checked · 7.6 km from downtown
Best for showing their workThirteen of the 79 reviews we read at the Ashton Court shop name auto repair, and the Tom-and-Scott-and-Miles trio gets named nearly as often. One driver came in after a tire shop told her she needed a tie rod; Tom's crew found wheel bearings and handed her the broken part.
Order this: Ask them to show you the old part
“If you want the best at a reasonable price, this is your place! I highly recommend Tom Dion's Auto Repair”
Tom Dion's Automotive Repair Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 24
Main Street Automotive
★★★★★ 4.8 · 82 Google reviews1858 Main St, Sarasota, FL 34236, USA · 4 of 52 reviews read mention auto repair (≈6 overall) · on 2 of 5 rankings we checked (google.com/search, google.com/maps) · 1.4 km from downtown
Best for drop-and-walkAt 1858 Main Street this is the most walkable shop on the list, 1.4 km from the center of downtown, with 4.8 stars from 82 reviews. Four of the 52 reviews we read mention auto repair, and it turned up in both Google search and Maps rankings for the term.
Main Street Automotive Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
- 25
Elite Motor Works of Sarasota
★★★★★ 4.8 · 495 Google reviews2277 2nd St Suite A, Sarasota, FL 34237, USA · 1 of 75 reviews read mention auto repair (≈7 overall) · on 2 of 5 rankings we checked (google.com/search, google.com/maps) · 0.8 km from downtown
Best for downtown walk-insClosest to downtown of anything here — 0.8 km, on 2nd Street — and carrying 495 Google reviews at 4.8. Only 1 of the 75 reviews we read uses the phrase auto repair, with about 7 overall, so it earns its spot on volume and proximity rather than on repair-specific raves.
Elite Motor Works of Sarasota Reviews →Own this business? Claim your free page
If you are choosing between the top three, it comes down to temperament. Sherman's on Gantt Avenue is for the mystery noise and the car you want kept alive — he will test drive it twice and tell you to wait rather than sell you parts. D & R on 8th Street is the price play, the one local shop every outside ranking we checked agreed on, and the reviews keep using the word "low." Automotive Service Garage out on Clark Center Avenue is the one for scheduled upkeep on a car you depend on daily: a named crew, transparent calls, and a steady drumbeat of "no upselling." Whichever you pick, call ahead, get the diagnostic fee and the hourly rate before you hand over the keys, and you will fit right in with the people who wrote these reviews.