213 E Lake Ave, Auburndale, FL 33823
Combined from Google + LinkToReview
Tap a star to share your experience.
Pizza Brothers operates an authentic Italian pizzeria in Auburndale serving New York-style pizza with house-made sauce, fresh ingredients, and specialty items like calzone and garlic knots. Opened recently, the restaurant is run by Italian owners Ivan, Lucca, and Fabio, who deliver attentive service in a comfortable dining space. Customers consistently praise the flavorful pizza, generous portions, and reasonable prices.
Local questions
Helpful answers based on customer feedback and business details.
Pizza Brothers is closed on Mondays and open Tuesday through Sunday from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM. Customers can call (863) 229-5760 to confirm hours or place an order.
Related questions
Pizza Brothers opens at 11:00 AM Tuesday through Friday and closes at 9:00 PM each day.
Yes, Pizza Brothers specializes in New York style pizza with authentic recipes and high-quality ingredients. The business is known for its flavorful pizza sauce, perfectly balanced crust, and traditional preparation methods.
Related questions
Pizza Brothers uses flavorful pizza sauce, a perfectly balanced crust, and traditional preparation methods that customers say rivals authentic New York pizza.
What customers say
“This has been our family’s favorite place since their second week of opening. Ivan, Lucca, and Fabio are the best Italians. They are very nice and attentive. Their pizza, is the best pizza in town!…”
— Alberto · 5★ Google review
Pizza Brothers offers garlic knots, mozzarella sticks, calzones, and stuffed pizzas like their meat lovers option, all prepared with the same attention to quality as their signature pies. The team serves these items with proper dipping sauces and sides.
Related questions
Yes, Pizza Brothers serves garlic knots and mozzarella sticks with proper dipping sauces, and their stuffed pizzas come with appropriate dipping sauce.
Disclaimer: These questions and answers are informational and are not official responses from the business owner or representatives. Please call or message the business directly to verify and confirm details on this page.
Good to know
Nearby restaurants: The Pantry Modern Diner (4.6 · 2,224) · Berkley Pizza & Wings (4.6 · 216) · Calogero's Pizzeria (4.7 · 734)
Featured by The Local Desk
Pizza Brothers appears in these local guides, built from real Google reviews.
What customers are saying
Curated highlights from public Google reviews.
Alberto
Google reviewer
"This has been our family’s favorite place since their second week of opening. Ivan, Lucca, and Fabio are the best Italians."
Empress
Google reviewer
"⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ We stopped by Pizza Brothers and it was honestly one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had."
Matthew
Google reviewer
"We've eaten here 10+ times since they opened a few months ago. It's that good. Best calzone I've ever had. Amazing crust."
Frances
Google reviewer
"First time ordering since its change and I have 2 say this pizza reminds me alot of new york. (Back Home to me) highly recommended."
michael
Google reviewer
"This place gets a 11/10 for me. My son and I ate the garlic knots and mozzarella sticks to start and they were just 🔥."
Fresh feedback
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience.
Write a ReviewBusiness snapshot
Pizza Brothers serves authentic New York-style pizza and Italian specialties in Auburndale, FL
Explore nearby
The Local Desk — best-of lists, hidden gems and reviews of the week, built from real reviews.
4.6 · 2,224 Google reviews · Auburndale · 1.8 mi
4.6 · 216 Google reviews · Auburndale · 1.9 mi
4.7 · 734 Google reviews · Lake Alfred · 3.9 mi
4.6 · 917 Google reviews · Lakeland · 7.8 mi
4.6 · 622 Google reviews · Lakeland · 8.0 mi
4.4 · 1,009 Google reviews · Lakeland · 8.6 mi
4.4 · 219 Google reviews · Lakeland · 9.5 mi
4.5 · 2,196 Google reviews · Lakeland · 9.5 mi
Own a restaurant like this one? Google Reviews for Restaurants: The Table Tent, the Receipt, and the Right Moment →
Also in Auburndale: Roofers (3)